I just got back from staying there and have to say I am a new fan. We stayed here because there were six of us at WDW, I got my son and his friend one room while my husband and I & my daughter and her best friend shared beds in the second connecting room. I got the rooms for about $140/ night each and we all fit perfectly. At first I wasn't thrilled because it looks so big and, at first blush- less Disneyfied that other resorts but I was so wrong.
At first there was a snafu, I am newly diagnosed handicapped due to arthritis and was worried about how big the place is so I had requested, 3 separate phone calls, a room near the bridge that would allow me to easily walk to the main pool etc. so buildings 51 or 45 Aruba or Jamaica. Mind you I called 3 times and at no point did they tell me I need to call the front desk directly about this - so make a note if it applies. When I arrived to check in at 10:30pm I discovered no one made any notes about this although they did have the fact my kids have asthma, and they put me much further out... so I just sort of cried worrying how I'd get around. I was tired and not feeling well and upset because since we had the kids friends we didn't go with The Polynesian which would have made everything easier on me so I sat and waited. It took about an hour, their first accommodation was to move us to Sarasota Springs, and although I mean no offense to fans, this is actually the one and only property I actually dislike the look of so I got even more upset and by the next time this woman came out they found us a spot. I wasn't expecting an upgrade because that's not how Disney usually does things, & really just wanted a walking distance room but I guess the fact it was a Thursday night softened the Mouses heart because we not only got convenient rooms but it was right in front of a pool. So yay for that, but this isn't why it was special.
The big pool was totally adorable, but full of little kids so for our 4 teens said in their words, "We're not about that lifestyle anymore" decided to settle in at the quiet pool and spent hours and hours happily playing water Frisbee & water catch so that worked wonderfully - The Poly probably wouldn't have given them the same escape because there are fewer pools.
AT night, after cleaning up and dinner, a nice walk around the lake was just blissful. We were in Martinique so I walked out to the walkway and made a right, enjoyed a hammock and dug my feet in the sand for a while before continuing along the walkway. The long wooden decks are just beautiful and as I rounded Barbados I saw a glimpse of fireworks and stopped to walk into the parking lot where I got an amazing view of The EPCOT firework show - just be warned I also got seriously bitten up by mosquitoes so use bug spray. After this I continued on my walk around and was able to enjoy listening to the Disney movie playing over at the big pool, so I stopped and grabbed another hammock while I was serenaded by Disney songs. It was just heaven. After a while I continued on to the walkway through Caribbean Cay to the big pool and really enjoyed seeing all the happy families and their little children splash and laugh in the zero entry pool. Next I stopped in Old Port Royale - at which point my daughter called to see if I was ok LOL, I was fine just people watching a bit. So I walked back past all the happy kids lined up in chairs watching the Disney movie of the night with their parents enjoying some grown up time at the bar area right alongside them and I thought to my self that this is, by far, the nicest family friendly set up I've been to. Now I haven't stayed at absolutely every resort (although its a quest of mine) but I walked away thinking that this is where I'm bringing my grandkids in 10-15 years
The busses were timely, the food court food was fine, internet reception was fine, phone reception was fine. Basically, other than the first night confusion it was as bump free as possible - loved it & so did everyone else in my group
That's my Caribbean Beach story, if you are going you'll probably love it