I just filled out our lunch pre- order last night for our visit in 3 weeks. All I've ever had is the braised pork and all DH has ever had, is the roast beef sandwich. We've had dinner there once and lunch there three times. It's the only lunch Where I eat something that heavy in the middle of the day- it's that good. Very tender,but not a lot.The portions are on the light side and the desserts are small, so we even allow ourselves to indulge there also. We've never eaten in the West Wing, as I find it a tad too dark. The one time we ate dinner there,it was so we could have a pic with the Beast. Although we enjoy and are fans of lunch, I have no desire to go back for dinner. The food was just okay and our table position was absolutely awful and we weren't given the option of waiting for a different table. We were right at the entrance to the ballroom and at the entrance to the Beasts' meeting area. It was like eating in the middle of Times Square. Just awful. Our next visit,for lunch,I was determined to find a decent table and we ended up in the back of the Ballroom,next to a window and next to the Christmas Tree,which had just gone up( last November). It was the first time we could see the falling snow and sitting next to the tree was magical! We do like the Rose Room,as it's peaceful,nice room between tables and you feel like you're getting a nice break in the day. To us,unless you're near a window in the ballroom,you can get the feel of being in a large,pretty cafeteria. It's a restaurant that has the ability to give you either a great or not so great experience,so you should plan on going more than once over your WDW visits.