Truly I don't think you can go wrong with either resort, so my vote is for a Villa...either way.
As a kid I loved everything "contemporary" and dreamed of staying at the CR. Then the GF opened not too long before my wedding and I immediately booked a suite for my fairy tail honeymoon. Being young and dumb I couldn't afford to keep that reservation...so I switched to the CR. Since that was 1991, the rooms are completely different, and I eventually divorced, the experience is irrelevant. But both resorts tug at my heart.
After seeing both studios and 2 br villas I have to say the "spoiled-factor" goes to the 1 and 2 br units (we'll ignore the grand-villas for this discussion).