I never heard any noise coming through the walls. If you are planning on leaving early and staying late then there shouldn't be a problem. We came back for naps in the afternoon and I don't remember it being a problem. The BWPPI is a motel - the corridors are on the outside which generally leads to more noise than a hotel. It's not a suite, it's a value hotel. You basically get what you pay for, which is a basic room at a price for much less than one of the hotels on property. In my opinion, you can't even compare the two. You have to look at each hotel on it's own merits and what is worth more to you - paying more to stay on property at a nicer hotel, or paying less and having more money to spend in the parks. Is price wasn't an issue I would stay on property. However, since we were on a budget we looked at what was most important - location. If having a brighter room or a bigger better pool was a priority then maybe we would have chosen another hotel. I just think it is unfair to compare the two properties as they really are apples and oranges. By the way, people have mentioned that the rooms seemed dark. This actually worked to our benefit since we wanted our son to nap and unless it is dark he won't sleep. Saved us bringing a blackout curtain. I also agree that walking to the monorail from the DLH could be longer than BWPPI since there are three towers, and there is no guarantee that you will get the tower you request. If you take the train you can get on from several locations and get off at the main station and be close to the main gate. I may be wrong but I think the monorail only stops in Tomorrowland - which can be a haul from Frontierland.