My personal favourite was actually a gift for someone else - I bought a large Disney fairy tale story book for my 1 year old niece on my last trip, and I then had characters sign their story (Peter Pan, Wendy and Tink on Peter Pan, Cinderella and Prince Charming on Cinderella, etc). Any characters that didn't have their stories in the book got to sign on the inside front and back covers. Now that she's almost 3, my sister says it is her absolute favourite book and they have a hard time keeping her hands off of it.
This almost makes me want to cry, what a great gift!!
Here are some of my favorites that I have collected over the years:
mini fridge picture frame, and I added a picture of our group from the trip
ornaments (as mentioned) are a great one! Definitely get it personalized and dated!
we got engaged in Cinderella's castle, so I have a keychain of the castle...it has held up so well and makes me smile every day!
coffee mugs...so many to choose from, but I always like to bring one back to add to the collection!
I love the idea of goblets to use every anniversary. When we got engaged at CRT, we got some champagne flutes that we plan to bring back to Disney to toast in our room for our first wedding anniversary this October. I'm a tradition girl, so i'm all about finding something meaningful that you can use year after year (or trip after trip)
We really regret not getting bride/groom ears on our engagement trip. We brushed it off as a frivolous thing that we'd only use once, but wish we would have had them for wedding photos, and plan to get them on our anniversary trip this time (hey...we are still "newlyweds"
).
I also do highly recommend getting the memory maker if you haven't already. We have SOOOO many pictures together from our trip. There is a little shop close to the castle that has a little photo booth. We got some great "couple" photos there before dinner with a nice background. They would be great keepsakes from your honeymoon.
This trip, we are planning on visiting the art store in Disney Springs (I don't know the name of it, but we visited last trip) and getting an original drawing or painting. A more pricey gift, but we're doing it as our "paper" gift to each other for our anniversary.
Love ALLL these ideas in this thread!