The Swolphin is also just as close.
Bluezoo
Il Muliano
Kimonos/Flying Fish
All great, in that order probably, although I rarely eat at IM since we have on in Nash now although the menu is slightly different.
Yep, Cape May was not good and we have 3 seafood lovers in our family. Crab legs were small/cold and were the best items available. Captain's Grille isn't bad. Yachtsman was very good but is a deluxe meal on the dining plan.I've tried the Cape May seafood buffet and wasn't a fan, I did enjoy the Captians Grille in YC though.
I'd also suggest Il Mulino at the Swan