I just held a 5B and a 9A stateroom for the Feb, 2012 sailing on the Magic. I'm really excited, this will be our first Disney Cruise and we'll also be celebrating our 25th Wedding Annv. But, I'm having trouble picking a stateroom. We had a balcony on the Royal Caribbean Lines and used it when coming and leaving from the different ports. We loved having the balcony but didn't like the way other cruisers near us would smoke on their balconies. The smoke would come up into our stateroom when the door was open. We weren't in our rooms much, so I'm not going to complain about the smoke. I really liked having the balcony give or take the smoke. On the other hand, my DH wants to save some extra bucks by having a oceanview porthole instead of a balcony. It's about a $700 difference between the balcony stateroom and the porthole stateroom. Since I had the balcony room once, will I be disappointed not having the balcony and going with the porthole stateroom in order to save a little bit of money? Why should I pick a balcony over a porthole stateroom or a porthole stateroom over a balcony stateroom? I have 5 days to make up my mind. Thanks.