Paula: Have you used or heard any reports back on either of non Disney shore excursion trips. There's a catamaran/snorkeling one that sounds really nice on the shoretrips.com site. Cost is similar, but the times work out a lttle better for me. I'm not big on early morning outings while on vacation and 12:30 should give us some time to walk around Key West beforehand.
Debbie
Debbie