Although we haven't taken our first trip yet (only 2 more weeks though!!) I have something that is very positive about all 4 of the WDW resorts:
How dang hard it was to choose my home resort!!!!
Disney did such a great job adding unique ammmenites to each resort, and each resort has its own flair...I really wanted to choose them all!
Here is why:
VWL: WL is my FAVORITE non-DVC resort, and I could go here and never see another thing at Disney and be happy. VWL is even better! I love the quiet serenity of the lobby and sitting rooms, and the grounds you can just get lost in. Add to that one of the best quiet pools around, and you really have a winner!
BCV: SAB!!! It really is a fun pool. But that isn't the only thing, although you often hear it is. On my last stay at the regular BC, one of the highlights of the trip was sitting in some chairs on the beach, watching the friendship boats go by. Also, watching IllumiNations from my Bed!! Also, the 5 minute walk to get some Fish and Chips!
BWV: Talk about a happening place! The actual Boardwalk area is so fun at night, but also a great place to enjoy a quiet morning with Espresso and a hot pastry! The locations is just as good as BC: Although you are a LITTLE bit further to Epcot, you are that much closer to MGM. Also, the opportunity to book those standard rooms at the 11th month window....makes for more Disney trips!!
OKW: Ahhhh, home sweet home!! I love this resort, and it did win out. Not because, as some say, it's "the one true DVC resort". They all are!! No, but OKW has such seclusion and serenity, and a feeling of a small community. Combine that with large rooms, a short trip to Comedy Warehouse or Adventurer's Club at night, and a nice low, low point cost, you can see what a great place it is!
As you can tell, I find magic in all of them and will be thrilled to stay in each one of them multiple times over the next 39 years!