We have stayed at least 4 or 5 times now on CL and have gotten a variety of gifts.
Most of these gifts were because of "celebrations" such as birthdays or anniversarys from what I recall. We have also been given gifts by CL CMs for our DD2 on more than one occasion.
Gifts have included carved wooden animal pens with these little resort themed bound books made from recycled paper, his/hers cologne/perfume bottles with similarly carved animal tops, the chocolate animal lollipops, a really nice pen/pencil set in a resort themed wooden case, resort themed chooclate plaque/picture frame, a leather-like african baobab tree statue, animal themed sippy cups, African themed baby spoons made in South Africa, animal finger puppets, a zebra change purse and stickers.
Yes.... they really like us I guess. Not only have we been repeat customers over the last five years but we tend to get very friendly with the staff to the point of them remembering our names from year to year. So that might have something to do with it as well.