4 or 5 night Bahama Cruise?

[Momofboys1011]

Good afternoon
We are new to cruising, and are planning on taking our first Disney Cruise this July. There are 3 trips that fit into our dates, but only 2 are really within budget, the 4 and 5 day Bahamian cruises.
Which one would you choose and why? The 5 day cruise is about $1,000-$1,200 more, but we would do it if its worth it. I am worried the 4 day will be too short, and that is the main reason I am considering the 5 day cruise.
Thank you all for your help!

 

[DISNEY FANTASY]

Longer the better!

 

[PrincessShmoo]

Good afternoon
We are new to cruising, and are planning on taking our first Disney Cruise this July. There are 3 trips that fit into our dates, but only 2 are really within budget, the 4 and 5 day Bahamian cruises.
Which one would you choose and why? The 5 day cruise is about $1,000-$1,200 more, but we would do it if its worth it. I am worried the 4 day will be too short, and that is the main reason I am considering the 5 day cruise.
Thank you all for your help!

I'm firmly in the "longer is better camp". If you don't mind the cost, I'd suggest that's the one you should do.

 

[MSPeeler]

We just returned from the 4 night Bahamian cruise on the Dream.... I wouldn't have minded another night/day. Next time we will do a 7 night!

 

[Club Disney Chandler]

Good afternoon
We are new to cruising, and are planning on taking our first Disney Cruise this July. There are 3 trips that fit into our dates, but only 2 are really within budget, the 4 and 5 day Bahamian cruises.
Which one would you choose and why? The 5 day cruise is about $1,000-$1,200 more, but we would do it if its worth it. I am worried the 4 day will be too short, and that is the main reason I am considering the 5 day cruise.
Thank you all for your help!

Without a doubt do the longer cruise, even if you have to go down in cabin category.

We've done 3, 4, 7 and 8 night cruises, have a 7 and 8 night cruises booked for next year and are planning on a 10 or 12 night for 2018. Cruises are so amazing you never want them to end!

 

[coffeecassie]

I have done a 4 day and a 7 day. 4 days was way too short for me to feel like I was on vacation. 5 day would be so much better and worth every extra penny! JMHO