First, I have to say that this is tied for our favorite meal of the trip! Before we left, I'd read a lot of mixed reviews for R&C, so I wasn't expecting much. We ended up having a wonderful meal! As many on the DIS have said, all restaurants will have good reviews and bad reviews, but you shouldn't let that stop you from making the reservation.
Originally, I booked R&C because I knew it had one of the best views of Illuminations. By the time the day of the ADR came, we'd seen Illuminations a couple of times, and we honestly didn't care if we saw it again from the R&C patio. Our ADR was for 8:20pm and we checked in at 8:10. The host gave us a buzzer, and we took a seat on the curb nearby. He asked if we had a preference between inside or outside. We said we didn't, so he gave us the first available table.
We ended up sitting inside, right at our 8:20pm reservation time. In the end, I'm really glad we sat inside, since even heat lamps don't always help me when it's cold, and it got pretty quiet inside later (especially during Illuminations).
We sat in the small seating area closest to the Pub, so we could see and hear the Pub crowd, but that didn't bother us. I felt it added to the atmosphere. However, people with a low tolerance for high noise levels might be annoyed.
Our waitress, Nikki, was very friendly and helpful. She started us off with some iced teas and warm rolls:
DH didn't think the rolls were that great, but I almost always like any bread I eat.
For dinner, DH ordered the chicken w/sweet potato pillow:
The chicken was so moist and delicious, but the real star was the sweet potato pillow. DH still won't stop talking about how good it was! I had several bites, and I can confirm it was outstanding! DH doesn't like pickled cabbage, but I do, and I thought that was also great.
I ordered the Surf and Turf, which had one fried fish strip, vegetables, steak, Irish potatoes au gratin, and Yorkshire Pudding.
I originally ordered this because I wanted to try Yorkshire Pudding and I was in the mood for steak. The best parts of the meal were the steak and the potatoes. The steak was cooked medium well like I wanted, and it had a wonderful flavor. The Yorkshire Pudding wasn't something I enjoyed, although I think it's authentic and made correctly. I just doesn't have much of a taste to it.
When we ordered the desserts, Nikki asked if we'd like any hot drinks to go with it. This was the first time I realized I could get a second drink with dessert (tea, coffee, etc.) as part of the DDP. I thought I was only limited to one drink. So, since we were in England, I ordered some tea.
Nikki suggested I have it with milk, the traditional way, so I did, and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
DH ordered an Irish Coffee:
It was pretty strong, so he was happy
For dessert, DH ordered the chocolate cake:
And I ordered the Bakewell tart:
I don't remember either dessert being a stand-out, but I do remember that DH and I switched desserts, and we were both a lot happier. What was really nice about dessert is that we got to take it slow, sip our drinks, and relax while everyone was outside watching Illuminations. The servers encouraged the guests at the inside tables to go outside and watch the show, so at least I know that we could've watched if we'd wanted to.
Total w/o DDP? $90.20 before tip
Atmosphere? We give it a 3. The decor and the raucous Pub noise made it feel British to us.
Service? That's a solid 4 1/2. Can't give it a 5, since we had a 5 during our trip and this wasn't quite as great. Still, Nikki couldn't have been nicer, and we always felt well taken care of.
Food? Nothing bad, and tons of OMG great! That's a 5 in our book.
Overall Rating? We're definitely going back!