Mama Melrose VS Sci FI

DisneyFansInNYC

DIS Veteran

Joined

May 28, 2012

• May 24, 2015

• #21

We love Sci Fi - we eat there every time. We love the atmosphere and love the food. The Salmon and Reuben is excellent. My kids love the hamburgers. The Milk shakes are delicious also. Mama Melrose was nothing special. I would choose the Sci Fi. Enjoy!

 

Grumpy247365

Mouseketeer

Joined

Mar 8, 2015

• May 24, 2015

• #22

Sci-Fi hands down. It's truly a unique dining experience.

 

scrappymel

DIS Veteran

Joined

Jun 6, 2010

• May 25, 2015

• #23

You will be ok with either. Food is good at both, but scifi is a neater experience. I like mama melrose' better for the food.

 

CampbellzSoup

Son. Husband. Father.

Joined

Oct 4, 2014

• May 25, 2015

• #24

Ask yourself where you live can you get good authentic Italian food?

Then ask yourself where you live can you eat in a 50s drive in movie esque environment?

Food is serviceable and the atmosphere makes it memorable.

The decision here is easy.

 

lmhannah516

Earning My Ears

Joined

Aug 6, 2013

• May 25, 2015

• #25

I didn't really care for Mama Melrose. My husband had an excellent steak but the rest of the food was only so so. We have reservations for Sci-Fi for our next trip.

 

goofyintoronto

DIS Veteran

Joined

Mar 29, 2011

• May 25, 2015

• #26

We LOVE scifi! Atmosphere is very unique. Its the coolest and quietest restaurant around! Where else can you watch movie clips while sitting in a car? Did I mention how quiet it is? Aside from that, the food for us has always been good. I love the picnic burger, and the shakes are to die for! Oreo is my fave.

 

goofyintoronto

DIS Veteran

Joined

Mar 29, 2011

• May 25, 2015

• #27

CampbellzSoup said:

Ask yourself where you live can you get good authentic Italian food?

Then ask yourself where you live can you eat in a 50s drive in movie esque environment?

Food is serviceable and the atmosphere makes it memorable.

The decision here is easy.

Click to expand...

Very well said!

 

Squirlz

DIS Veteran

Joined

Oct 31, 2000

• May 25, 2015

• #28

Never been to MM and have no interest in it. SciFi had the best burger I've ever had at WDW.

 

A

allwritemel

Earning My Ears

Joined

May 2, 2015

• May 25, 2015

• #29

I enjoyed both but my meal at Mama Melrose was fantastic! Best one I had while I was in America, bar none