We really enjoyed our YC stay! We ended up at the far end of the YC, pretty far from the lobby and pool. We asked for a ground floor room, close to lobby and day bed and received ground floor room with a day bed. I was ok with the location as our water view had an amazing view of the high Illuminations fireworks.
We found the distance between the YC and BC to be maybe 2min, even from our far out room at the YC.
We chose the YC as we wanted a patio or a full balcony and the YC has a much better chance at getting one vs BC which has many rooms with a juliette balcony or no balcony. That would be a deal breaker for us.
We found the YC to be quiet even in the summer, it was lovely.
Cape May dinner buffet is our favorite restaurant in all of WDW. We stuff ourselves on crab legs and shrimp.