La Spezia
The plan: Take the train to Pisa as early as possible, get the obligatory 'holding up the tower' picture. Get back to the train station ASAP to spend as much time as possible in Lucca.
The outcome: This is another tendering port and it takes much longer than Villefranche since the tenders hold 325 people and they take forever to fill. We must have waited 30 minutes from the time we were told a tender was available to the time we were on our way to shore (plus 15 min waiting in the theatre). So rather than walk to the train station, we followed the sign to the cab stand, which had pleny of cabs (in spite of a guide book which said 'few cabs' were available). The cost was told ahead of time - 15 euros. It was worth it! The walk to the train station in La Spezia is not direct, and very much uphill!
The trains run on time! Exactly according to the online schedules. And they are easy to print and bring with you.
Again we tried the automated ticket machines at La Spezia train station but our card was rejected. The nice man at the counter spoke very little english and set us up to get to Pisa but I didn't want to confuse him with my elaborate plan to go Pisa to Lucca and then Lucca to La Spezia. So off we went. The ride was not bad at all - very scenic, the train was not crowded. Got off at Pisa Rossore, no problem.
Here it gets tricky, I had a map from tomsportguide that showed taking a left right off the train to get to the Pisa area. But the crowd was going straight and wasn't sure what to do. To be safe, we followed the crowd which walked past Pisa University (most of the train riders were students). Then we took the left turn to Pisa. It wasn't direct but I felt safer. Pisa was awesome, I'm glad we went. The vendors were even fun to stop at. (TIP: If you are participating in the FE exchange and don't want to haul stuff overseas, consider buying some of the many 2-3 euro trinkets at the Pisa booths to give away!)
We spent maybe an hour at Pisa, having gelato and waiting in the super long restroom line. Then we walked back taking the tomsportguide path. Yikes!!! I do not recommend that route at all! A few non sanctioned vendors sell all sorts of random stuff along the sidewalk on this route back to the train station, knowing tourists come this way, and they are pushy and the neighborhood is not good. No one else was around and we did feel uncomfortable, wishing we'd taken the Pisa University route instead.
The San Rossore station did not have an attendant so I believe we used cash to buy a ticket to Lucca since it wouldn't take our card. There is no indoors at the San Rossore station, no restrooms, no officials around, it almost seemed deserted except for a handful of passengers.
The train to Lucca was quick, maybe 3 stops and there we were. You can see the walls of Lucca in front of you when you exit the station. You have two choices, either enter the side entrance straight ahead, or take a left and go a few blocks and go in the main gate. If you like. We rented bikes and biked the wide path around the city, against the walls. They had a little kids pink flower bike for my 11 yr old. It was so peaceful and beautiful. Kind of like the Sound of Music scene where they are riding the bikes! There were walkers and joggers to dodge but it wasn't bad. Many quiant picture taking spots along the way.
Thanks my DH's download of 'offline maps' map of Lucca, we found our way through the twisty alleys to the Piazza where we ate pizza and gelato and drank lemoncello. (There are many more roads than the guide book maps illustrate.) Then we biked to the Guingi tower and went up the long climb - since we did not do the Pisa climb. This was much shorter, cheaper, and less crowded than the Pisa tower. I knew when my DD complained at about the 100th stair that we'd made the right choice not to climb Pisa!
We went back to the rampart and biked the rest of the 2.5 miles around the town. I regret that we did not have enough time to explore any of Lucca's museums or churches, but what can you do? Bike rental was 24 euros for 4 bikes for maybe 2-3 hrs. We had to catch a 4pm train back to La Spezia since it was a 1.5 hr train ride due to a train change in Viagreggio (no direct train from Lucca to La Spezia). And I wanted to make sure we made it back to the tender by 6. Otherwise I could have biked that rampart all dayy! (Side note: If you enjoy biking Lucca, check out Mackinac Island, Michigan someday.)
Lucca is an attended station with a tiny cafe and the bathrooms shown in my post. We easily bought a ticket to La Spezia and the guy was great about telling me how to switch trains in Viagreggio.
Switching trains in Viareggio was tricky as a train to Florence was on our track when we got there and we almost got on! I asked another passenger "La Spezia"? And she was like "No, No No, Firenze!"
Ok, you may be sick of my potty reviews but I've got to tell you one more about the bathrooms at Viareggio station. There is a line of what looks like 4 elevator shafts. When you deposit 50 cents the metal doors open and you and walk in like an elevator, with the door slamming you in. A sign said you had 5 minutes to 'do your business' at which point the doors automatically opened so you better not have your pants down! LOL. Also note that the station in Viagreggio has a kickin newsstand with Italian Glamour and Italian Vogue magazines.
We taxi'd again from La Spezia station to the port (plenty of taxis!) for another 15 euro and got in the long tender line back to the ship. Arriving at the ship at 630 for our 600 dinner seating, the staff at the ship telling everyone "If you have early dining you must be seated by 645 or they cannot serve you, go go go!" So we went do dinner, all sweaty and tired but happy to have had such a wonderful day.
If I could go back and do it again: Other than bringing a train map print out, I would not have done anything any other way. I talked to others who paid hundreds to take the Dis tour to Pisa and Lucca. I'm sure they had fun but we were able to travel at our pace, experience the Italian railway and spent less than 20 euros per person on train tickets. As lovely as I hear Cinque Terre is, I have to say, I'd go back to Lucca in a heartbeat.