While Tony's is not a "must do every trip" kinda restaurant for us, we do like it.
We ate there in 2011 & 2012, &, this year, we're trading it for Be Our Guest.
I love the "Lady & the Tramp" theme... so cute! If you're collecting character autographs, be sure you give your autograph book(s) to your server. Lady & the Tramp "hang out" in the kitchen, & your server can get their autographs for you.
We enjoy sitting in the sunroom because I like the bright, airy feeling, but the main dining room looks nice too - there's a cute Lady & Tramp statue in the middle of the restaurant. And, unlike lots of other WDW restaurants, I don't find the tables as close together - they're still close, but not as close! There's also patio seating which is nice - sitting on Main Street, soaking up the atmosphere. And, if you time it right, you could end up w/ a patio seat during one of the parades.
The waiting area is nice too, & it's always semi-crowded to crowded, so, apparently, other people like the restaurant as well! LOL!
We've also always had fine service.
Is it the best restaurant in WDW? No. But it's not the worst either. It really is fine - I'm not sure why it always gets such bad reviews.
For appetizers, the zucchini fries are really, really good! And DH said the calamari is fine.
For entrees, I really like Shrimp Scampi - it's light & flavorful. It has always tasted fresh to me. In the previous years, DH has always gotten the pork or steak entrée, but, last year, he got the Cannelloni. He said it was only okay. Our kids like the Spaghetti & Meatballs, & younger DS LOVED the Mickey Ravioli.
For dessert, we get the Tiramisu which is good. The kids enjoyed the Ice Cream Bomb.
Here are some pics from our dinner last September...
Kids' Spaghetti & Meatballs w/ Side Salad -
Kids' Mickey Ravioli w/ Apples -
Shrimp Scampi -
Cannelloni -
Kids' Ice Cream Sundae -
Tiramisu -
And here are some pics from inside the restaurant...
The Main Dining Room w/ the Lady & the Tramp statue & fountain -
Same pic, different setting on camera -
One of the windows of the sunroom -
Hope this helps some!! Give Tony's a try!!