Quick Thoughts on Mama Melrose

[GeorgiaHoo]

Had lunch today at Mama Melrose for the Fantasmic dininig package. Were seated at our reservation time of 12:25. Bread and drinks came out fairly promptly. Package includes appetizer, entree, dessert and drink. I had the calamari which was fine, daughter liked her caesar salad, wife thought the mozzarella and tomatoes were just ok and sons did not like the antipasto plate. I had the chicken campanelle, youngest son had the penne with chicken and four cheese sauce, oldest son had the NY strip and wife and daughter had spaghetti and meatballs with four cheese sause. The NY strip my son had was excellent. The pastas were all good but the four cheese sauce is a cream based sauce that is very heavy/cheesy. Although good we couldn't eat too much of it. Probably would have been better with the marinara. And the portions were huge! Dessert was a sampler tray that was good.

 

[tammilynne]

Had lunch today at Mama Melrose for the Fantasmic dininig package. Were seated at our reservation time of 12:25. Bread and drinks came out fairly promptly. Package includes appetizer, entree, dessert and drink. I had the calamari which was fine, daughter liked her caesar salad, wife thought the mozzarella and tomatoes were just ok and sons did not like the antipasto plate. I had the chicken campanelle, youngest son had the penne with chicken and four cheese sauce, oldest son had the NY strip and wife and daughter had spaghetti and meatballs with four cheese sause. The NY strip my son had was excellent. The pastas were all good but the four cheese sauce is a cream based sauce that is very heavy/cheesy. Although good we couldn't eat too much of it. Probably would have been better with the marinara. And the portions were huge! Dessert was a sampler tray that was good.

thanks for the review! we have the fantasmic package booked and have never tried it .. always enjoy reading a good review

 

[GeorgiaHoo]

I was a bit apprehensive based on some poor reviews but I found Mama Melrose to be prefectly ok. Not as good as 'Ohana but still fine.

 

[bradleyjess]

So with the package you each get an appetizer? Not just one for the table?

 

[Crystal824]

I enjoyed Mama Melrose in November. I think it is a bit underrated.

 

[wiigirl]

I enjoyed it.

 

[minnie mum]

So with the package you each get an appetizer? Not just one for the table?

The appetizers are per person. The dessert sampler is for the whole table (and is adjusted to the size of the group). Be aware that at least one of the appetizers is made "for two" (at least it was when we were there). In this case 2 people in the party would share that particular appetizer.

OP, thanks for the review. I agree with your son- I was really surprised that one of the best steaks I had at WDW on our last trip was from Mama Mia. I also agree about the 4 cheese sauce- it is always very, very rich and filling (not just at WDW)!

 

[hoffmase]

we (me, wife, DD5, DD4) ate dinner at Mama Melrose in April 2012 as part of the Fantasmic package. We thoroughly enjoyed the food.

i would eat there again in a heartbeat.

 

[sydneysmom]

The appetizers are per person. The dessert sampler is for the whole table (and is adjusted to the size of the group). Be aware that at least one of the appetizers is made "for two" (at least it was when we were there). In this case 2 people in the party would share that particular appetizer.

OP, thanks for the review. I agree with your son- I was really surprised that one of the best steaks I had at WDW on our last trip was from Mama Mia. I also agree about the 4 cheese sauce- it is always very, very rich and filling (not just at WDW)!

Quick question, if you don't mind.... if we're on the deluxe dining plan, would this work the same way? Would they still do a dessert sampler ? And do you get to choose from the menu or is it a special (limited) menu for the fantasmic package? I appreciate any help....we've never booked Fantasmic package, so I'm a complete newbie on this one!

 

[minnie mum]

Quick question, if you don't mind.... if we're on the deluxe dining plan, would this work the same way? Would they still do a dessert sampler ? And do you get to choose from the menu or is it a special (limited) menu for the fantasmic package? I appreciate any help....we've never booked Fantasmic package, so I'm a complete newbie on this one!

Deluxe DP, DDP or OOP, it's all the same, since it's a pre-paid meal. Appetizer, entree, dessert sampler and non alcoholic beverage. Everything except the dessert is chosen from the regular menu.

 

[sydneysmom]

Deluxe DP, DDP or OOP, it's all the same, since it's a pre-paid meal. Appetizer, entree, dessert sampler and non alcoholic beverage. Everything except the dessert is chosen from the regular menu.

Thank you!

 

[imlsherman]

We make it a point to eat here every trip. My wife and I call it the one adult meal. The food is good and if you do the package it is well worth it.

 

[jhryb]

I too love Mama Melrose. I usually get the Chicken Parmesan but I had the steak on my recent visit and it was a great choice