Hello there!
I just spent an embarrassing amount of time reading your trip report when I should be crunching statistics on my research for my graduate thesis.
I especially enjoyed your pithy writing and candid view of your entire trip from start to finish. Normally I just lurk and read, but I just had to respond...
First, I believe I have a glimpse into your future. My Conor, age eight (yes, the Irish spelling. Yes, people goof it frequently) is so amazingly similar to your Conor. Right down to the medium brown hair and dark eyes. Anyway, now in third grade, he is just as inquisitive and talkative as he was at age four, albeit with more social graces than before. He is more comfortable conversing with adults and older kids than children his age, but I wonder if it is because he has no siblings and he spends a fair amount of time with adults. I laughed heartily at your recounting of how many times you played the Mystery game aboard the ship. We had a very similar experience at Great Wolf Lodge and the MagiQuest game. I'm sure your Conor will love it once he's about age six and beyond, if you ever go someplace that has MagiQuest. Reading about his antics (we too had sneaky pee) sparked a similar trip down memory lane.
Second, as for the whole Disney thing and the magic... Interestingly, one of my father's duty assignments was Southern California so I visited
Disneyland a few times in the two years we were there. Fast-forward nearly 20 years and my husband and I spent our honeymoon in Disney World - first time either of us had been. It just looked like fun (and it was. Exhausting, but fun). So, 16 years later, we finally went back to DisneyWorld and we took Conor with us. We had a blast but, like you, don't see the need to go with any regularity. Don't get me wrong, I don't think we are anti-Disney, we just aren't (gasp!) Disney fanatics.
With that said, many of our friends that have sailed
DCL are similar to my family - not anti mouse, but not fanatics either and they all have said they enjoy DCL the best for many reasons. So, we are looking at the possibility of going on a DCL cruise this year - which would be a record for us. Two Disney trips in decade.
Oh! I will end with this... So, we have already talked to Conor about the possibility of booking a DCL cruise and he surprised me with his take on the Disney characters. He said that he felt sorry for the people that had to dress up. He thought that it must be roasting in the costumes, hanging out in the Caribbean sun and heat. I explained to him that this is their job, they get paid to do it and that many of them actually enjoy it as it brings smiles to people's faces. He thought about it for a second and he said, "We'll, I'm glad that they make people happy. I wouldn't want to be on vacation with unhappy people." I think he hit the nail on head. A vacation is what you make of it. And it seems that you all have a great time, despite not being fanatics. And you, I surmise, are not alone.
Fabulous TR!