I have stayed at all 3 DLR hotels, with my favorite being the DLH because it felt the most Disney to me. They were all very nice, and if any of them could come close to the rates I can get offsite, I'd stay there again, but for the money, I can't justify staying onsite. In February DH & I are staying at the Ramada Maingate and from what I am reading, the walk to the parks will be even shorter than it was when we stayed at PP, and no further than the DLH. If we were taking the kids (20th anniversary trip, so no kids!) or if it was during a more crowded season, I might put more value on the early entry option that comes with staying onsite, but since it's just the two of us and it's early February, while it would be nice to get a head start, I don't think it's essential, certainly not worth the several hundred dollar difference it would cost to stay onsite.