I do think for a longer stay staying onsite is nice. And when you use points (as I do) you really get a good deal. Rack rates are high right now and points are pretty reasonable. You also won't pay tax (very high in So. Cal) and the nightly resort fee (around $12). That resort fee includes free internet access, USA Today paper Mon-Fri, and health club access as well as parking. And since its part of the Disney Collection, you do receive daily maid service. I like having the dining choices, nicer pools, and many other amenities a deluxe level resort can offer. Most of the nearby motels to DL are motels, with none of those amenities. And the per point cost of using your points will be very nearly the same as what you pay to stay offsite.
I do agree with 1FoolishMortal that staying onsite isn't quite as big as WDW. But really only because of location. Unlike WDW, there are dozens of nearby, walking distance motels to DL. However, they are a clean room and a place to sleep with very little in the way of magic or amenities (unless you go with the Hilton or say Embassy Suites, but none of those are walking distance and what you will pay a night will probably be more than what your per point cost is. At least that has been my experience). For longer trips (esp offseason when hours are shorter, therefore you are in the room more) I very much prefer to stay onsite. However, staying offsite will be just as convenient. And I have several good experiences with the nearby motels on Harbor Blvd. Definitely if you are paying cash and don't end up using points, staying offsite will save you some money. Many of those nearby motels have a free continental breakfast. But I generally don't like to do that for stays of longer than four nights. But then I have stayed onsite too many times and its hard to turn back once you do!
I have used my points at Disneyland a few times now and will again in January. For me it works, for some it doesn't. However, if you have the points available, I would go for it!
------------
for us the end of
June '08 @ lowest priced studio onsite property for 8 nights using points ($10 per point cost comparison) vs most of the well-regarded harbor blvd hotels is well over $1 K
, unless DL resorts run a heck of a cash promo, think we'll soak up the ambiance whilst we're in the park & use the $ saved elsewhere on the trip.