I've stayed at all of the All Stars (Sports 2x, Music 1x, Movies 2x) and Pop (3x) and we prefer POP. I like the feeling of Pop and there is a great path along the lake. I have never noticed any of the noise issues in all of our trips, and I am a teacher and have super hearing LOL. I like the pop jets area at Pop, the trivia along the walking paths, the hustle and the twist dancing in the lobby, frozen coke available in the food court, a great grab and go area in the food court, two bars, the retro music, and I could go on and on.
I don't like to eat in the food court for breakfast as it is very crowded. We bring poptarts and the like and have a light breakfast in the room and then either have a late breakfast or an early lunch in the park. There are microwaves available in the food court and we also like to bring our own popcorn.
Since POP opened we haven't been back to the All Stars. That's how much we love POP!