We have stayed at all the east coast
DVC resorts except VGF and AKV...we have a trip to AKV in just 9 days (and will see where it falls on the list). Of the ones we've stayed at, here's my order of preference (DH has VWL up higher on the list...like #3 after BCV and BWV):
1- BCV (location, location, location...and quaint/quiet, lots of dining options)
2 (tied)- BWV (next best location but hate long hallways and villas are small)
& OKW (quaint/quiet, large villas, great busing if stay near hospitality house)
3 (tied)- VWL (very quiet but too dark, woodsy and deserted, like boat to MK)
& BLT (great to walk to MK, lots of dining options...but noisy resort and I hate monorail, though good for stroller families...high point cost)
4- SSR (very bland, busing was worst for us here, small villas...good for folks who like DD but we don't all that much)
***We are a family with 3 teens who aren't into pools so much anymore (do like the hot tubs, especially after all the walking at the parks). We love Epcot and are all about dining at WDW. We ride the headliner rides but don't do parades, shows, kiddie/classic rides or character lines anymore. So, we may have a different perspective than those with little ones who do like some of the things we don't.
We also have stayed at VB and HHI...added on points at HHI so that should tell you what we thought of HHI (we have a 2nd trip booked there for Aug). But, I am guessing you are only interested in WDW resorts.