Atmosphere is better at cape May. Nice theme. More going on. It's a buffett so there is more action there. Also Character Breakfast. The clam bake buffett at night is good. There were better ones at Disney but it was good for the most part.
We enjoyed our food at the Galley and it was quiet which was very nice after a long day in the parks for DH and myself.
If I had to pick one i would pick CM and I'm sure my husband would pick the Galley LOL
I think it depends on what kind of mood you are in. Both are great places. The Galley is vey quiet and has a limited menu but the food and services has always been good.
The Cape May is always a hopping place whether it's for breakfast or dinner.