Wicked or My Sister's Keeper for Book Club?

[Tinijocaro]

Tomorrow night is our first book club,we read These is My Words by Nancy Turner. I also read the sequel Sarah's Quilt.

I get to choose the next book- Love some input- Wicked or My Sister's Keeper?

Jackie

 

[angelam]

I haven't read "Wicked", but have read "My Sister's Keeper". I like most of Jodi Picoult's books, and this was one of my favorites. The ending is very emotional.

-Angie

 

[Madaboutthemouse]

Both books were great! I thought My Sister's Keeper was a little easier to follow and read faster than Wicked. But, I really enjoyed both! Good Picks!

 

[pam66]

I haven't read Wicked but I did read My Sister's Keeper for my book club and we loved it. It gave us a lot to talk about! I think you would really enjoy it

 

[Cindy B]

Sisters Keeper.. really good book. I couldn't get into Wicked.

 

[Sparx]

I've read wicked, but not the other.
Wicked is dark, and pretty risque at points. Its a long read, and I wouldn't even start if you don't REALLY want to read it, trust me. you won't finish. jmo.

 

[Briarmom]

My bookclub has done both of these books and I'd have to go with My Sister's Keeper. Wicked is awesome, but it took a lot more time to get into, and thusly most of them were not finished with it at the next meeting. 'Keeper' is a fairly quick read.
Both are good though!

 

[The LK 4]

I thought Wicked was a horrible book. I struggled to read the whole thing. It was way too political for my tastes. Two of my friends agree that it's the worst book they've ever read.

 

[Tinijocaro]

Thanks for the input ladies- My Sister's Keeper it is!

Jackie

 

[jedi_librarian]

Good for you! You'll LOVE it. I just lead a book discussion at my library on it and it was a great discussion..

 

[Syrreal]

I thought wicked was a great book until it got to the very end. The end just kinda seemed anti-climactic.