We stayed at the All Star Movies last February. We are going back again. We loved it. We have the idea that a hotel needs to be clean, have a few amentities (like a pool, someplace to eat), and be well kept. We don't need to be wined and dined. The All Stars are great for us. We stayed in the Dalmatian area.
We prefer a more simple restaurant, so the food court was great for us. I thought the food was awesome. Maybe a little expensive. The rooms were not overly big, but we did great with three of us. We are doing four this time. Transporation was good. We didn't have to wait long for buses. There were times when DH had to stand, but I usually had a seat with DD who was 4.
If you make a reservation you will be told that Fantasia is the preferred section. It is closest to the main pool. However, Toy Story and Dalmatian aren't much further. Don't pay the extra to stay in Fantasia.