I don't lilke the pretty men either... personally I don't want to be someone whose hair is better than mine! (good reason DH is bald!)
I dont get Ashton, Brad Pitt,or even Tom Cruise now.. Same with Ben Affleck, or even Matt Damon.
I think Anthony Edwards is cute.. (I must like bald men!). I also think Noah Wylie has aged quite nicely as well. Personally, I loved the look Nicolas Cage had a while ago... but not lately. He looked really good in one movie, but I can't remember which one... but lately its been downhill. I like the ones that are funny, and make me laugh, and are intelligent. STING is one hottie!!!!! I coould drool (oh I mean look) at Sting till the cows come home..... Peter Gabriel is sexy too.