Which is your top pick: Citricos, Narcoosees, Yachtsmen SH

[honeyhall]

Out of these three options, which is your top pick: Citricos, Narcoossees, Yachtsman Steakhouse. Please vote!

 

[ededmd]

Having eaten at all three, I'd rank:
Narcoossee's
Yachtsman
Citricos

Narcoossee's has more creative variety - fish, pork, even vegetarian; the only one of the three for which I have repeatedly booked ADRs.

If you want steak, go to Yachtsman - would eat here again.

Citricos was fine as far as the food, not great but okay - but the service was what would keep me from going back.

 

[kaybird]

We have eaten at all three. I have loved Citrico's each and every time, the chef has always come to greet us at the table. The crab gateau is so great I would book just for that!

Narcoosee's is a solid second. We have always had great meals there.

 

[Mickey'sApprentice]

I've only eaten at Yachtsman's Steakhouse, but YUMM!

It is SO Good!

 

[Pakey]

I've eaten at all 3 several times.

I'd rank them

Citricos
YSH
Narcoosees

 

[honeyhall]

This is all great information, thank you! Keep it coming!

 

[JDUCKY]

Definitely Citrico's first. Hands down!

Then Narcoossee's for the location (great view of Wishes from our table)

Then Yachtsmen

 

[BEASLYBOO]

Citricos, if I don't have a notion of what I want to eat, however if I want a good steak I would choose Yachtmen!

The food is good at all 3, you really can't go wrong!

 

[honeyhall]

Bumping, thanks for the votes, its very helpful!

 

[Pooh&OurHunny]

Narcoossee's

 

[wyonative78]

As someone previously said, you really can't go wrong with any of them. Yachtsman is one of my favorite restaurants I've ever dined at anywhere. I have eaten many, many steaks at all different types of restaurants, and the filet mignon at YS was the best steak I have ever had anywhere. Holy cow, was it good! Service was also superb.

Citrico's and Narcoossee's were both good, but I just didn't enjoy them the way I enjoyed Yachtsman.

 

[Marcy in FL]

Love Narcoossee's!
Then Yachtsman
Then Citrico's

 

[disneydreaming4now]

They're all good. By rank, IMO, Narcoossees and Citricos are a close run. My husband would choose Narcoossees then Citricos. It's a hard decision for me. Then Yachtsman...

 

[rubato]

Citricos!

 

[honeyhall]

Keep voting, thanks everyone!

 

[skorpie]

Can't really vote yet but we have Citrico's booked for our adults only trip in January!

 

[Silver Queen]

My vote was for Citricos. The other two restaurants are also good, but not as good as Citricos. My impression of Yachtman's was diminished by the fact that the AC was extremely cold. They actually offered me a tablecloth to put over my shoulders because the cold air was blasting so hard.

 

[aubriee]

I've eaten at all three several times and would choose Citricos. I love, love, love their crab gateau and their steak and pork loin are both good. They used to have the most wonderful berry gratin on the menu, but I haven't seen it there in several years. They've got a chocolate/banana tart thingy that's pretty good though. Narcoosee is great for steak and lobster if you are on the DDP, although I usually substitute scallops for the lobster and they also have a good almond cheesecake. Yatchsman I have yet to be impressed with. I much prefer the charcrusted steak over at Flying Fish to any I've had at Yachtsman. At Yacthsman I've had the strip, ribeye, porterhouse, and also rack of lamb. I enjoyed the lamb more than the steaks. They used to have a really good seafood salad appetizer, but it hasn't been on the menu for awhile and I have yet to find a dessert I'd have to repeat there (I've had their sorbet several times, mango cheesecake, and banana Napoleon).

Honestly of all the Signature restaurants I like Flying Fish the most. I love their mussels, cheeseplate, or tomato/mozzarella for appetizers, char crusted steak or scallops for entrees, and any of their dessert trios for dessert. Flying Fish is the only restaurant where I consistently love all three courses of my meal.