Which is better for dinner Chef Mickey's or 1900 Park Fare?

[disneypolybride2008]

Hi. We've booked CM for dinner but w/ the reviews maybe we should switch to 1900. We have not done either for dinner before. Which would you choose? why?

THANKS

 

[Evan&Kimberly]

I loved 1900 Park Fare for Dinner!!! Someone had mentioned something about the birds flying over Chef M's this just caused me to change my mind I had many thoughts of the birds and etc.....

 

[tigger_03]

We ate both for dinner. They were both good. The kids had a blast seeing Mickey & the gang but they also loved Cinderella, Prince Charming, the step sisters, and step mother. I laughed so many times during our dinner at 1900 Park Fare. I know it's a meal that we will do again each time we go back to Disney. So glad we opted for the 1900 Park Fare meal over CRT (we decided we'd wait until DD was older - she was 3 during this trip).

 

[aheape1979]

We ate both for dinner. They were both good. The kids had a blast seeing Mickey & the gang but they also loved Cinderella, Prince Charming, the step sisters, and step mother. I laughed so many times during our dinner at 1900 Park Fare. I know it's a meal that we will do again each time we go back to Disney. So glad we opted for the 1900 Park Fare meal over CRT (we decided we'd wait until DD was older - she was 3 during this trip).

We also ate at both for dinner on our trip last week. We have 2 daughters, and they LOVE princesses, so 1900 PF was probably our favorite for characters. The chilled strawberry soup makes me salivate just thinking of it. All in all, the food was comparable at both places. I would do both if you could, but choose which one has the characters your children like best.
Also, we ate at CRT and thought that the food at supper was just mediocre. Mine and DH's pork chops were over-cooked and tough. Once again, characters were good, though, as well as the general ambiance. We will try for breakfast next year when we go.

 

[Tam1067]

We had both for dinner in early August.

Food was better at 1900 Park Faire, no question. Our service there was terrible, though. But Chef Mickey's food was pretty dismal, and service was mediocre.

 

[disneypolybride2008]

which had better desserts?

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Chef Mickey's In my opion the have the better desserts