Which ADR to cancel??

[Fionasmommy]

I really want to make room for dinner at WCC, but can't decide which of our ADR's it should replace. Help!!

What should go?

Chef Mickey's
Coral Reef
1900 Park Faire
Le Cellier
Mickey's Backyard BBQ
50's PT
Concourse Steakhouse
Liberty Tree Tavern

 

[Christine]

Assuming you have young kids, I'd cancel the Concourse. You will have already eaten at the Contemporary once. I've yet to go to WCC, but I don't think you should miss eating over at the Wilderness Lodge. It's a nice place.

 

[disneyplanner]

We've been to almost all you have listed and in my opinion, I would give up 50's Prime Time cafe. I don't think it's all it's cracked up to be, The decor is great, but the food wasn't very good. However, we loved Whispering Canyon and had a blast there!

 

[katiesmom2]

Another vote for ditching 50's prime time. The atmosphere is fun, but you can peak in as you walk by just the same. The food wasn't all that fabulous. Definitely a good idea to squeeze in WCC - we really enjoyed it!

 

[bicker]

Sacrilege!

Seriously, I love 50s Prime Time -- I couldn't imagine going two trips with a visit to it. I agree with Christine (again!) and suggest that Concorse Steakhouse is the one most eligible to be bypassed. It's okay, but just okay.

 

[Wendy31]

Assuming you have young kids, I'd cancel the Concourse. You will have already eaten at the Contemporary once. I've yet to go to WCC, but I don't think you should miss eating over at the Wilderness Lodge. It's a nice place.

I totally agree with this. I'd also cut out Concourse Steakhouse since you're eating at Chef Mickey's. I think both restaurants are right beside each other, so the "setting" (characters & menu items aside) are basically the same.

Plus, you can get steaks at Le Cellier and/or Coral Reef.

Chef Mickey's - at the Contemporary, keep this ADR - fun character meal
Coral Reef - at EPCOT, keep this ADR - steaks & seafood on menu, unique setting
1900 Park Faire - at the GF, keep this ADR - beautiful resort, great buffet, & good characters for a little girl
Le Cellier - at EPCOT, keep this ADR - It's Le Cellier!
Mickey's Backyard BBQ - at FW, keep this ADR for the experience, FW is nice w/ lots to do while you're there (pony rides, watch Wishes from the beach, etc.) [Edited to Add - The Hoop Dee Doo show at FW does generally get better reviews than Mickey's BBQ. Can you switch your ADR to HDD?]
50's PT - at MGM, keep this ADR (but I'd probably do Sci-Fi or a FDP instead)
Concourse Steakhouse - at the Contemporary, cancel this ADR - you'll be at the Contemporary w/ Chef Mickey's & you can have steak at Le Cellier or Coral Reef
Liberty Tree Tavern - at MK, keep this ADR - 1 of the best character meals!

 

[DisneyMomx7]

Mickey's Backyard BBQ. We did it our first year when the kids were 2, 4 and 5 and I honestly felt we were at a free for all. There was no organization and kids were just running to the characters. I thought my little ones were going to be run over.

I wouldn't give up PTC, its one of our favorites and Concourse has much better food that Mickeys BBBQ or WCC.

 

[jonimce]

We did not have a good experence at Mickey'y BBQ either.

 

[Sleeping Jedi Beauty]

Isn't backyard bbq signature dining? I'd drop it since WCC is not signature dining. It would at least be cheaper that way.

 

[LVSWL]

Concourse Steakhouse. We just didn't think it was all that great. The wait staff was kinda snotty and the steaks were not the best. We enjoyed some of your other choices much more.

 

[ImagineEar]

Another vote for dropping the BBQ. You'll dine with Mickey at Chef Mickeys.

 

[snowwite]

Concourse or the BBQ. We didnt think BBQ or Poly Luau were worth the money we paid.

 

[bicker]

Mickey's Backyard BBQ does require 2 TS credits per person.

 

[cara loves the poly]

The Coral Reef was our biggest disappointment.

 

[YesYourMajesty]

I would ditch the 50's Primetime as well. Although, if you are not staying at the Wilderness Lodge and are heading there just to eat during a break from or after you leave the MK, then I would ditch one of the restaurants in the MK area....Concourse, Chef Mickeys, Liberty Tree, etc.