Where should we eat at Disney Hilton Head?

[Sammie]

Oyster Factory is a favorite and we too have never gotten bad service or food at Guisippe's at Shelter Cove.

 

[momsully]

We just got back from HH and had a great meal at Oyster Factory. We also had pizza one night from Mellow Mushroom which was excellent.

 

[Dean]

Hemingways was great, best meal of the trip I'd say, other than Wild Wings but it's certainly in a different category.

 

[EpcotMatt]

So getting back to the original post, it doesn't look like many folks have tried many of the places on my original list, huh? I guess we'll just see what we feel like when we get there & skip the list too.

 

[Judique]

I’ve posted this message on a few other boards as well, but wanted to get as wide a variety of opinions as possible. My DW & I will be driving down to Disney & will be stopping at Hilton Head for the night & will be staying at the Disney Resort there. We should be getting there about 3:00 or 4:00pm and we’ll be leaving the next morning at 7:00 or 8:00am, so we won’t be there long. But we’ll definitely be eating dinner there.

As a way of saving a few bucks, I was thinking of checking out restaurant.com’s list of Hilton Head restaurants. Here’s a list of the participating places:

B-5 Bistro
British Open Pub
Callahan’s Sports Bar & Grill
Corner Stone Grill
Del Vecchio’s
Flavor’s
Giuseppe’s {edited: had Flavor's & Giuseppe's on the same line. Sorry for the confusion.}
Island West Grille
Main Street Café & Pub
Mickey’s Pub
Nick’s Steak & Seafood
Parrot Cove Café
Plantation Café & Deli
Prescott’s Steaks & Seafood
The Studio
Upper Crust

Does anyone have any reviews, positive or negative, of any of these places? I can get a $25 gift certificate for only $5 to any of these places. Or do I just stick with my choices in the Disney resort? If that’s the route I should take, what are your suggestions for the places inside the Disney resort? And why?

I can comment on a couple from experience:

Studio - we had a very nice dinner here. It is a nice room with piano music for entertainment. With all the options on the Island, we probably won't go back - we have some favorites that are better for a nice dinner out, but it certainly wasn't bad.

Callahan's Sports Bar and Grill - okay - casual.

Giuseppe's - It's not gourmet pizza. It's not Domino's or Pizza Hut. It sort of reminds me of Sbarro -maybe not as good. A calzone or a salad or even spaghetti and meatballs is a better choice if you go here. But on a budget with your gift certificate I'd make it work as fast food and it is very close to the resort.

I wouldn't count on eating at Disney - Tide Me Over closes at 5 pm. It's basically fast food anyway.