Where can I find great peanut butter desserts?

[gillep]

My favorite is the brownie at The Mara at AKL. The pie at Contempo Cafe is a close second but I thought that the ratio of crust to PB was off for my tastes, I ended up just not eating the crust at all. Not a fan of the PB&J milkshake, not enough PB flavor for me. I am very interested in trying this drink at Flying Fish!

 

[Tonyz]

This may be sacrilegious but... I didn't love the Contempo Cafe pie. And I went to the Contempo specifically to get it!

Certainly not bad, just IMO not as amazing as I was hoping it would be.

I'll throw a vote to the Mara brownie.

 

[Fairest Snow White]

I enjoy the No Way Jose from Beaches and Cream at Disney's Beach Club Resort.

Disney Food Blog has an excellent video on peanut butter desserts here:

.

Have a magical vacation!

 

[MaryKM]

I thought of this post today as I was watching a Disney Food Blog video on Animal Kingdom. Evidently at Zuri's Sweet Shop, there are peanut butter goodies called "Haystacks" and they are basically peanut butter clusters - but with potato sticks. Sounds intriguing, right?
The DFB reviewer loved them. Here's a link to the write up.

 

[juuuliebeth]

If you ever find yourself in Disneyland (or if they ever hopefully bring it to Disney World) there is a Peanut Butter Sandwich in their confectionery cases. It's graham crackers with a peanut butter filling covered in chocolate. Unbelievable. The peanut butter cups are good as well.

I've also heard that the Boardwalk Bakery has had some PB treats, but I haven't been and I'm sure they rotate.

 

[nicolebridget22]

The peanut butter brownies at The Mara and the CL lounge in AKL are heaven on earth! Counting the days til my Sept trip so I can go ham on those things!

 

[HokieSLP]

We have a peanut butter lover in our family - me!!
So where, in the World, can I find a peanut butter dessert? Pies, Cakes, Ice cream. Anything!

We'll be going to all 4 parks + Disney Springs in late July.

I'm so glad someone else posted this before me

 

[DeniseJH]

I'm so glad someone else posted this before me

Always good when you're going in with all the important info!

 

[jolynne28]

This is probably a sin, and I was pregnant when I ate it, but the Starbucks at HS has a chocolate peanut butter cupcake that I thought was pretty incredible. It was huge but I managed to take it down with very little sharing.

 

[Dean Kennedy]

PB&J Milkshake at 50's Primetime. The best PB item available at WDW in my opinion.

Mine too, it’s marvelous.

 

[nco91590]

I know this might not be the most exciting option, but I had the best peanut butter cookie OF MY LIFE at Big Top Treats in MK. Such a low key confectionary masterpiece. Unassuming lil old cookie that was soft and chewy with big chunks of PB and peanuts. So good and I highly suggest

 

[DeniseJH]

I know this might not be the most exciting option, but I had the best peanut butter cookie OF MY LIFE at Big Top Treats in MK. Such a low key confectionary masterpiece. Unassuming lil old cookie that was soft and chewy with big chunks of PB and peanuts. So good and I highly suggest

Yes! I have had these as well. I don't care for crazy cookies with tons of different things in/on them, and these simple peanut butter cookies are just perfect!

 

[Burgundy Rose]

This thread is heaven. Thank you so much for starting it, @kylovebug

 

[LavishWig]

I saw on DFB recently that the ice cream parlour on Main Street at Mk has an incredible looking peanut butter sundae! I’m definitely going to try and get my hands on it next month.

Edit - link: http://www.disneyfoodblog.com/2019/...s-plaza-ice-cream-parlor-live-up-to-its-name/

 

[Best Aunt]

Apparently the Peanut Butter Brownie at Joffrey's in Epcot is very good:
http://www.disneyfoodblog.com/2019/07/03/im-dead-over-this-new-peanut-butter-brownie-in-epcot/

 

[nco91590]

Apparently the Peanut Butter Brownie at Joffrey's in Epcot is very good:
http://www.disneyfoodblog.com/2019/07/03/im-dead-over-this-new-peanut-butter-brownie-in-epcot/

Adding to my list! OMG

 

[Minnesota!]

PB&J Milkshake at 50's Primetime. The best PB item available at WDW in my opinion.

They have (had?) this at the Plaza, too, in MK. FANTASTIC!

They used to have this layered "torte" if you will at Boardwalk Bakery. Chocolate, PB, and bacon. It was divine!