You really should repost this question right after Halloween and call it...
Which Candy Do I Steal First From My Kid's Halloween Haul?
If we're strictly looking at candy bars and not just candy in general, I have this bizarre love for Almond Joy. Twix and Kit Kat are second and third. Now, I won't turn down a Milky Way or Snickers and 100 Grand and Baby Ruth are pretty decent too. If I veer from the more common, I might go for a Skor, Hershey's with toffee bits, Caramello, Chunky, or something Lindt.