I love it!! It sounds like POTC is the favorite, DL is the best version in IMHO. We had so much fun at WDW but being at Disneyland is just a little different, from the light in Walt's apartment to the Matterhorn to special rides on the Lilly Belle it's just so.... I don't know, sweet maybe?
It's been really interesting to me starting to plan this next trip, I've never been as anything but a local AP holder, I've been going my entire life and have never even bought a day ticket before. It's kind of fun switching gears and having a new experience at an old favorite.
There are certain attractions that if closed, we will we will re-schedule or trip around. Those include IAJ, POTC. After that we kind of have a policy of not going if two or more of OUR favorites are down.