What's the best thing you've eaten at these restaurants?

[MSLRAC]

We ate at a handful of your picks last trip and here's what we really liked...

Sci-Fi ~ the Reuben, onion rings, BLT soup and peanut butter chocolate dessert

Rose and Crown ~ the shrimp and barley appy, scotched egg and bangers and mash

Liberty Tree Tavern lunch ~ pot roast, turkey dinner, declaration salad

Tutto Italia lunch ~ Bufala Mozzarella, Penne Caprese

Narcoosee's ~ surf and turf, whole lobster, crab cakes, almond cheesecake

 

[tkitna]

Sci-Fi - Beef and Blue Salad (Ironically, the rest of the family had the ribs and thought they were horrible. I tried them and agreed.)

Liberty Tree Tavern - Pot Roast and Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake

 

[disneyfan551]

The Plaza - the Reuben gets me every time! (And usually with so much meat, that I ask them to leave 1/2 off!)

The Tollhouse milkshake is wonderful & so is the banana split!

Enjoy!

 

[MickeyNicki]

Sci-Fi -We always get the burgers and onion rings, they are delish!

The Plaza - The best fries in all of WDW! The reuben and cheesesteak were terrific

Via Napoli - Love the salad, love the pizza but the best was the spaghetti and meatballs

Liberty Tree Tavern lunch - DH devoured the pot roast, he loved it. I had the chicken and dumplings and it was more like a chicken noodle soup but it was excellent

Tutto Italia lunch - I had the proscuitto sandwich, awesome!

Narcoosee's - Loved the cheese plate and the heirloom pear salad...didnt like the entrees at all

Kona lunch - The best place for lunch in all of WDW! I had the teriyaki steak salad that was delish but DH had the lunch plate with chicken, macaroni salad and sticky rice....this was to die for!

Fulton's - You cannot go wrong with king crab claws and fried lobster tails!! The house salad with balsamic dressing is the excellent

Raglan Road - Our entire meal here was terrible...the fried calamari was a nightmare, the food was just horrid and the bread pudding was nasty

 

[Colleen27]

Sci-Fi - stick to the burgers and onion rings! the spinach-artichoke appetizer was pretty good too, but they don't generally do a great job with their more involved dishes. REAL cherry Coke - not premixed but Coke with added syrup - keeps me coming back.

The Plaza - everything we had was good, not spectacular or unique but well-prepared sandwiches in generous portions with nice crispy fries and delicious ice cream. the cheesesteak could have used a bit more cheese, the reuban and club were both excellent

Liberty Tree Tavern lunch - the pot roast is to die for, but on the heavy side for lunch. the turkey was good as well, I didn't try the burger but it was HUGE and smothered in mushrooms just the way DH likes it. the appetizers were solid American food with plenty of crab in the dip, and the smaller cheese on the fried cheese plate was quite nice.

Tutto Italia lunch - we've only been for dinner. I loved the lasagna but it is a very large portion and very heavy, again just not my idea of lunch food. the tomato & mozzarella app was nice and fresh and the lemon sorbetti was perfectly light and refreshing after a heavy past entree.

Narcoosee's - we've been there twice and nothing of my appetizers or entrees really stands out in my memory. I don't eat lobster but usually make an ADR there for my lobster-loving DH & DS. they do, however, have the most incredible almond crusted cheesecake dessert.

Raglan Road - really loved the scallops. the shepherd's pie was good but very heavy (probably great for meat & potatoes types), dessert was pretty much lost on me. I wasn't feeling real well that day and was outright sick the next so my impressions of the meal probably aren't the most accurate; we're giving it another try this week.

 

[Smiling Cheshire Cat]

Thanks everyone for taking the time to respond.

It sounds like the cheesecake at Narcoosee's has a 100% approval rating.

 

[jabead]

Sci-Fi - Burgers, shakes, and vanilla cokes

Rose and Crown - Fish & chips

Tokyo Dining - Never been

The Plaza - Haven't been since 2006

Via Napoli - Pepperoni pizza, Zeppole di Catarina for dessert, Rosa Regale

Liberty Tree Tavern lunch - Cheeseburger, Pot roast, Tavern fried cheese

Tutto Italia lunch - Nothing really

Narcoosee's - Shrimp & Crab chowder, Whole Maine Lobster, Surf & Turf, Filet Mignon, Almond-crusted cheesecake

Kona lunch - Sticky wings, Banana-Chocolate Creme Brulee

Raglan Road - Fish & Chips and desserts, especially Ger's Bread & Butter Pudding

 

[jelliott04]

I'll comment on the ones that I can remember what I liked best:

Sci-Fi : haven't been in a long time, shakes are good here
Rose and Crown: Sausages
Tokyo Dining: Can't remember
The Plaza: Veggie sandwich (can't remember the name but it is very tasty)
Via Napoli : Going 1st time next week!
Liberty Tree Tavern lunch: Blech
Tutto Italia lunch: I think we had a tasting of sorts here and it was good
Narcoosee's: Blech...Blech...Blech. Go to Citricos instead.
Kona lunch: The sushi is good here and just about everything else too
Fulton's: One of my favs
Raglan Road: Another good choice. French Fries with malt vinegar

Good luck!

 

[stinie18287]

Raglan Road is one of our favorite restaurants. I had the "Serious Steak". Here's the description from All Ears Menus: 10 oz sirloin topped with Irish whiskey marmalade glaze, with fresh basil oil, mashed potatoes, and topped with crispy fried onion strings... it was AWESOME

Also had the Bailey's Creme Brulee which was officially the best thing I ate during the whole trip

 

[ChristaDeVil]

Rose & Crown - Surf & Turf. Yummy!