What to pay OOP for?

[twogirlsandthatsit]

On our upcoming trip in September we will be on the DDP (7 nights). We have made ADR's for 8 places with one of them being CRT, so that totals 9 credits. I am trying to figure out which ones would be the cheapest to pay out of pocket for.

Here is our list of ADR's, I would love your opinion. THANKS!
Raglan Road dinner
Chef Mickey's Bkfst
Mama Melrose Dinner
Liberty Tree Taver Dinner
CRT lunch
Tusker House bkfst
Whispering Canyon Dinner (not sure if we are going to keep this one at all)
Askerhus Dinner

 

[Disneychix]

I would say one of your non-buffet dinners but I'm not sure how you like to eat. Will you still be getting desserts for eveyone while not on the dining plan? What about drinks? I find if I'm paying OOP I generally will drink water and not get dessert. Whispering Canyon is expensive if getting the platter but if just ordering a regular meal it's not too pricey (well accd to WDW standards!).

 

[butiflfeet]

Usually breakfasts are the cheapest but with your 2 ADRs being buffets that can vary depending on the time of year and how much they cost at the time. You can check http://www.allears.net for menus and from there get an idea of what you would likely order and how much it would cost.

 

[bluejasmine]

I agree pay OOP for breakfast they are ALWAYS cheaper

 

[OhThePain]

I am another one who finds that breakfasts are always the cheapest to pay for OOP.

 

[Hootch]

somewhat. If you keep WCC, I'd pay OOP for CRT. If not I'd look at the Tusker House breakfast.

 

[Cafeen]

With 2 little ones, if they're going to be ordering kids meals at the non all you can eats, I'd look at paying OOP at either WCC or Raglan for them, and paying OOP for Tusker for the adults.