We tried Ohana for the 1st time on our last trip in 2008. We enjoyed it so much. (yummy). So I will have to say it is Ohana with a Le Cellier as a close second. We have ADR's for Ohana for our Aug trip. We tried for Le Cellier but none available. Will keep trying.....
Best Food:
breakfast- Main Street Bakery or Crystal Palace
lunch- Cinderella's Royal Table (but they don't serve my fave anymore... pork tenderloin w/ mustard cheese grits)
dinner- Tony's Town Square
Best Adventuresome Food: Boma (try something new)
Best non-Disney food: Wolfgang Puck Cafe (Pumpkin Ravioli!!!)
Best Drinks: the now-defunct Rock-n-Roll Beach Club at Pleasure Island (literally a bucket of Paradise Punch!)
Best snack: Mickey Premium, Minnie Strawberry Bar, or Dole Whip
Best Dessert: Chocolate Wave at Coral Reef
Places I'll never eat again... Le Chef de France and Brown Derby
just asked the wife and she shocked me with her answer. Mama Melrose. Thought for sure she was going to say Ohana's or California grill. She threw me a curve ball.
Narcoossee's was a wonderful experience. Great food, amazing service, and a wonderful location and atmosphere. Flying Fish is competitive in terms of food and service, but it gets a lot louder, which for me takes away from the atmosphere.
Jiko, Sanaa and Citrico's are on the list for the next trips, though, and I am willing for any of them to take the top spot. It will be tough, though.
Best View of Fireworks: California Grill
Best Service (thus far): Narcoosee's and California Grill (tied)
Best Food: Coral Reef (yep- we loved it!)
Best Entertainment: Teppan Edo
Best Character Meal: Princess Akershus
Fast food--Pizzafari, just because of the Deli sandwich. Nowadays anything that isn't considered a "special" of a particular QSF restaurant is the same exact burger/pizza/chicken strip/dessert you will find at all the other QSF restaurants.
Best start to finish magical meal experience for us was Le Cellier on our honeymoon. We're headed back there in just about 2 months and have booked it as the last TS meal of our trip. I just hope that it lives up to our memories of that night.