Originally posted by Another Voice
... one as to wonder why a studio so renowned for its timeless and joyful movies would associate themselves with this one.
I, personally, have never thought of Miramax as a studio renowned for its timeless and joyful movies. (Although they DID give us the Hellraiser series.) Yes ... I know ... Disney is the parent of Miramax and therefore they should be aware blah, blah, blah.
Miramax also released Chicago, which had sex, murder, scantily-clad women in jail dancing in a fairly nothing-left-to-the-imagination way, a matron who was just this side of a lesbian, and the underlying theme that crime can, indeed, pay. Not exactly wholesome family values in the true Disney tradition. And Chicago was rated PG-13 -- you could bring KIDS to that! "Loves Labours Lost" -- they let Kenneth Branaugh SING, for goodness sake. Was THAT necessary? Was THAT in the Disney tradition? And yet, no outcry. No claims of disrespect.
I will never see "Kill Bill." Didn't see "Pulp Fiction" either. Not my cup of tea. But I appreciate that my stock jumps when they do well. If the film had been released as a Disney film, then I'd have been outraged. As a Touchstone or even a Hollywood film, I'd have had pause. But Miramax has its own brand, into which "Kill Bill" settles nicely. When Disney acquired Miramax they did so specifically to gain a place in that independent film niche, and I think the consumer understands that. It's not like the film is marketed as "Disney's Kill Bill," and it's not as though parents are thinking "ooh ... it's a Disney film ... I'll take the kids right after we see Finding Nemo."
Originally posted by Another Voice
Sadly, Disney no longer respects its own audience and this is the result.
Disney's audience is clearly the family / kid audience. Miramax's audience is clearly not. I don't see how Miramax releasing a violence laden film equates to Disney not respecting its audience. I'd rather see something like "Kill Bill" under a Miramax banner (where I know what Im going to see -- strong language, extreme violence, sex and multiple decapitations) than to see something like "Snow Dogs" under the Disney banner (where I expect to see ... oh, I don't know ... character development? Story?). Disney disrespects its audience when it releases things like "Return to Neverland" or "The Country Bears" in theaters.