Vignetting question

My2Girls66

DIS Veteran
Joined
Mar 1, 2004
Messages
1,782
What causes it? I noticed it on some of my photos taken in Florida with my 18-135mm lens. Seems the pictures were all taken at 135mm and I did have the hood on. I may have had a CP filter on also but am not sure.
example...
482234310_cxGFw-M.jpg
 
i think it is actually sometimes just an actual lens( something about the way the elements are can make it vignette, i think that is probably worse with relatively cheaper lenses). also using some filters ( like a graduated nd filter) can cause it on wider angles.( like with cokin filters you need to buy a wide angle holder) and sometimes just the way the light hits the hood or filter can cause it. if you were using the right hood and don't usually have the problem with that lens i would guess it was the filter. i think sometimes you get a natural vignette looking area in really wide angles but that wouldn't be the case here. i think it's the aperture so not sure how the 135 could affect it. most of what i have read about it seems to be with a wider angle rather than a narrow angle and they tell you to stop down a bit to help get rid of it. do you remember if they were they all taken same equipment ?
you might be able to fix it in lightroom if you use that. there is a place for lens distortion. i actually like a light vignette to kind of easy out the edges and point toward the middle although that might be a little to dark for that.
 
I actually don't mind it on any of my shots. I cropped some of the shots so it was cropped out of those. I was just wondering if I was doing something wrong to cause it. I don't recall seeing it before with this camera/lens combo. They were all taken with my D80 and 18-135mm lens, hood that came with the lens and probably a CP filter. I have sent this lens back to Nikon twice for an F-- error(the camera wasn't reading it all the time) and also thought that maybe they did something that adjusted it wrong:confused3
Thanks for the reply! :)
 

Vignetting is worst when using a lens at widest aperture. If shutter speed allows, stopping down your aperture will help. 1 stop is usually enough to make it unnoticeable, depending on the lens.

Optical vignetting is caused by the unavoidable fact that a lens has length. Check out the second picture in this article, it helped me understand the concept.
 
It is extremely easy to correct in post processing, especially if you shoot in RAW.
 
I get vignetting with my 18-250mm, even at 250mm, when using it wide open. Stopping down eliminates it.

As ukcatfan mentioned it is also easy to correct in post processing.
 
Thanks all, for the replies and links. Very interesting! I couldn't find anything that explained it well.
 
Sometimes stacking filters (using a UV protective filter then putting a CP filter on top of that) can also cause vignetting at the wider focal lengths
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE











DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top