Every resort has pros and cons. We've stayed at nearly every resort on property except DVC (and ASSp to get particular). Pop is among my top picks! Although one of the things I like at Pop is the transportation to the parks.
I agree attitude is much to do with it. And all of WDW, your experience depends on the particular CM's you happen to get. We've stayed at some resorts more than once; one time we get all great CM's, another time we get a bad one- and that tempers the experience.
I always love just exploring a new resort, and you'll have the option of checking out TWO resorts should you desire.
One thing about the lake at Pop- unlike the mods- the lake is off to one side. You don't have to walk across the lake every time you come and go from your room. (big plus!) If you have a car, you might want to request to be near the parking lot. I prefer the 90's section, based on location.
I agree the food court at Pop is great. Lots of choices, great set up. Kept very clean.
There are no big downsides to Pop. I only wish there was pool slide, coffeemakers, and a nice TS option. The rooms aren't huge or elaborately decorated, but they are fine for a quick stay. Also the beds are not queens.