We went during Christmas. We went inside, but there were only bar seats. My mom has a bad back, so we couldn't really do the stools. We sat outside, instead. Even though we didn't get the antics, we still really enjoyed it. It was a very warm night and being outside was awesome - especially knowing we'd be heading back to cold New York.
It's worth noting that you can order drinks without the souvenir glass. It's not that my dad didn't wanna spend the extra money, but he was worried about carrying it home. I still got it. They're pretty awesome. I THINK I went with the HippopotoMai-Tai. It was good, but a little too lemon-y for my liking. I wanted something a little more sweet than sour. Looking back, I wish I got the spikey pineapple or the tiki tiki tiki tiki rum. I think my sister got the shrunken zombie head and really liked it. My mom got a non-alcoholic drink.
We didn't try the food, as we were stuffed from 'Ohana. They had outdoor entertainment, which was awesome.
If you don't like rum, this might not be the spot for you. It has fun drinks, but I can see non-rum drinkers not enjoying it. If you don't like rum, try the Hangar Bar.