My DH and I were on the Magic in May, and Topsiders had a menu the evenings we were there. They also had a small but nice salad bar. We loved eating there. We had asked for a small table on our regular rotation, but ended up at a table for 10. So for a break in the routine a couple of nights, we turned to Topsiders. It was so quiet and relaxing there. Very few other guests were there when we were (in fact, the other guests were some of the ship's officers), so we had a table to ourselves, next to the windows. Great service, naturally, and I believe the food was similar to that offered in the dining rooms. Topsiders is an especially nice option for return cruisers who have done the rotations before and are looking for something in between the all-out dining room scene and the counter-service alternatives.