Tony's or Mama Melrose

[Angela0917]

Which do you like better? I don't want to do 2 Italian places 2 days in a row, so we are going to only pick one. The second choice for Hollywood Studios is 50s Prime Time, but I'm not sure about second choice for Magic Kingdom. Somewhere close so we can make 7:00 main street electrical, any suggestions?

 

[MickeyNicki]

While we like them both and have been to both many times we prefer Tonys over MM....the calamari is so much better at Tonys too!

 

[Sweet Melissa]

It's my opinion that Tony's is better than Mama Melrose ... but it's also my opinion that they are the very worst and second worst Italian restaurants in Disney World.

 

[mtopaz]

Hmmmm..since when is Electric Parade at 7pm? Its still light out. You might want to double check on that one.

 

[DEA]

I would rather not eat than eat at Tony's again.

I have not eaten at Mama Melrose's, so I cannot compare, but Tony's is my absolute worst Disney restaurant, and that is saying a lot when ABC Commissary is also on the table...

For a TS in the Magic Kingdom, you're going to be limited to The Plaza, Liberty Tree Tavern, Crystal Palace, and CRT. Crystal Palace is okay, but it is a character meal. It is close for the parade, though. A quicker meal could be had at Columbia Harbor House, for a CS meal.

 

[Sweet Melissa]

Hmmmm..since when is Electric Parade at 7pm? Its still light out. You might want to double check on that one.

They're going in November. It will be dark at 7:00 PM.

 

[gabzee]

I would choose Mama Melrose over Tony's.

 

[billfatora]

While we like them both and have been to both many times we prefer Tonys over MM....the calamari is so much better at Tonys too!

I'd do "Tony's" and "Prime-Time" !

 

[eeyoreforever]

I like both Tony's and Mama Melrose, but I'd go with Tony's just so I could do Prime Time. So yummy!!!!