I'm playing it now. Its a really solid game with a lot of meat when you get past the initial it plays like WoW. My advice, find a well populated server, and have fun.
MMO's are going to have a tough time. Folks are becoming bored with them. I played Lotro for about 3 1/2 years before I moved on to WoW (didn't last long because of the low populations) and then Rift. Now, I'm with a great guild and one of the leaders in it. The odd thing is I can't tell if I'm getting older (35) or if I just don't want to play video games anymore, because I think about doing more and more in RL. Its strange. I love the people I play with for the hours I play (late PST), love the game, love the raids, and yet, I think more and more about just walking away from gaming.
Sorry, I think I'm tired and now I'm rambling ....ahhaha
I know what youre feeling. I played UO prior to care bear land. I payed for about 2.5 years. After I quit, I didnt MMO for 9 years.
Now, Im in WoW. The newness is definitely gone, but I still am having fun. And that is truly what you all should be thinking. Are you playing out of habit, or because, "it is fun"?
I quit when there is no fun
Something else to remember. MMOs suffer from maturity. The game grows beyond story, beyond patches, etc. Most of the game is been there done that. People just move on. WoW did something that was considered forbidden in MMO terms, and that was to wipe and start over *the Cataclysm*
I personally think it fell short of a potential. They essentially replaced the old game with a New old game.
I like what they are doing with some of the new content. I think they should have done this with the previous races. Some of the biggest complaints are the Racial differences in PvP. The Extra trinket for humans, the AOE crowd control for Tauren and Blood Elves. These translate to huge advantages over other races in a drilled down PvP (Arena)
The factions should be the original 5. Any new races should be allowed to choose what faction from here on out. Drania, Belves, Goblins, Worgens and now Pandas should all be allowed on either faction.
The only reason we still play WoW is because, there isnt anything new. Someday, down the road, the new MMO will supplant WoW as the big MMO. That road may be The Old Republic.....