We stayed on the hotel side and didn't find the room to be dark/dreary at all. I actually really loved it! I suspect we might find our VGC studio to be more rundown and drab this summer so I have my expectations set a bit lower. It's a good thing there are all types of
DVC resorts for all types of tastes.
I am a bit worried they will cheap out and the refurbishment will not be great. Will that make me regret purchasing a contract? Nope! The location really can't be beat. And after years of being a local and never staying in hotels in the area (well, except for the old Anabella once) followed by over a decade of staying off-site on Harbor......I'm really happy that future trips will be at VGC. The whole "feel" of our Grand Cal trip last year was so different than staying other places.
I'm excited to see BRV in a couple weeks (though I never saw it pre-refurb) and hopefully I'll like the room and it will give me hope for a good VGC refurb!