I am going to put my 2cents in and I don't think it will be a popular one. We are all creatures of habit and there is nothing wrong with that, especially when it comes to Disney. After going to WDW for over 30 years and staying at just about every hotel and multiple restaurants, I will admit I have my favorite places but I have found that each restaurant has a "cult like" following and if anyone says a negative thing against it - watch out! With that said, I will give you the advice I have given friends and co-workers who go to WDW and ask me about certain restaurants; "I can't tell you what you want to hear, my opinion is that, my opinion. What I like may not be what you like but if you want to try (insert restaurant name) then do. How will you know if you don't try?" I also tell them that there was a time when I listened to others when it came to WDW restaurants and my dining reservations and that last maybe two trip or so. So what changed - easy, I realized I was missing out on some great places all because others gave me their opinions. From that trip forward, I stopped asking others their opinions on the restaurants because they are all subjective and based on the experience at the time. So to the original poster I offer my advice: don't go but wait till another trip and if you want to try something different this time, start small with a quick- service or a different menu item at a place you do like. Good Luck.