The Official Harper's Island thread starts 4/9/09....

[Disney1fan2002]

I know Abby's mom knew that Henry was the son she gave up, you could tell by the way she looked at Mrs. Dunn in the flashback. But I don't believe the Sheriff knew or he would have told Abby when she first learned Wakefield had a child, at least IMO.

Did Henry ever say if he killed his parents, the Dunns? How much older was Henry than Abby, does anyone know?

You bring up the questions I have. We all assumed we would find out what happened to Henry and JD's parents, but we didn't. Did Henry kill them? How old was Henry when they died? I thought he was a teenager, and JD was much younger, but the scene where his parents came to pick him up with JD, he only looked like he was a year or two younger then Henry.

Also, the scene where Abby's mom was looking at Henry and then at his mother, you could tell she regretted giving him up, or that she at least had a mother's love for him. So, when his parents died, why wouldn't she have moved the earth to welcome him intot the family? She could of used the excuse of how close he and Abby were, that he was already a part of the family. We know Uncle Marty took JD in, was Henry in college?

So, did Abby's mom give birth to Henry before she met Abby's dad? She must have, so why did the writers have them so close in age? Henry can't be more than a year or two older than Abby.

It's almost like they hadn't decided WHO the killer would be, and just chose Henry along the way.

OH OH!!! ETA... I thought the most ridiculous part of the show was Trish changing into her wedding dress. I knew the minute she did that, she would be a target, having to run away in a wedding gown. The minute Henry locked her in, she should of been ripping herself out of that dress and putting her sweatpants and running shoes on.

 

[DISUNC]

It's almost like they hadn't decided WHO the killer would be, and just chose Henry along the way.

I think you hit the nail on the head! With maybe 3 episodes left too write, I assume they put 5 character pics on a wall...and threw a dart...wherever it landed THATS DA MOIDERER.

All these people Knew henry for his whole life, All his friends from College...etc...and NO ONE ever thaught..".hmmmm this guy is odd"?

Besides Mass Murders are usually loners....that why I was thinkin Jimmy!

 

[2BigKIdz]

You bring up the questions I have. We all assumed we would find out what happened to Henry and JD's parents, but we didn't. Did Henry kill them? How old was Henry when they died? I thought he was a teenager, and JD was much younger, but the scene where his parents came to pick him up with JD, he only looked like he was a year or two younger then Henry.

Also, the scene where Abby's mom was looking at Henry and then at his mother, you could tell she regretted giving him up, or that she at least had a mother's love for him. So, when his parents died, why wouldn't she have moved the earth to welcome him intot the family? She could of used the excuse of how close he and Abby were, that he was already a part of the family. We know Uncle Marty took JD in, was Henry in college?

So, did Abby's mom give birth to Henry before she met Abby's dad? She must have, so why did the writers have them so close in age? Henry can't be more than a year or two older than Abby.

It's almost like they hadn't decided WHO the killer would be, and just chose Henry along the way.

OH OH!!! ETA... I thought the most ridiculous part of the show was Trish changing into her wedding dress. I knew the minute she did that, she would be a target, having to run away in a wedding gown. The minute Henry locked her in, she should of been ripping herself out of that dress and putting her sweatpants and running shoes on.

When she was running through the woods with the wedding dress on I told my husband she was thinking putting this dress on was not a good idea

I believe on one episode it was revealed that Henry was in college when their parents died, that's why Uncle Marty took in JD but not Henry. I know that scarred cop said JD and his dad came to visit him in the hospital so we know they were still alive after the first Wakefield murders 7 years ago.

 

[LisaR]

I just have to ask something that is driving me crazy but totally OT. Why is my name being quoted multiple times on this thread but the quote is never anything I wrote? I have never seen that happen before. I thought I was losing my mind because I didn't remember writing any of it!

 

[2BigKIdz]

I just have to ask something that is driving me crazy but totally OT. Why is my name being quoted multiple times on this thread but the quote is never anything I wrote? I have never seen that happen before. I thought I was losing my mind because I didn't remember writing any of it!

I think there is something wrong with it right now. If you see the previous post that says original post by 2bigkidz, I did not post that but she had quoted me but her response appears as if it is my original post. The actual post I made that she quoted is not present. I'm probably not making any sense

 

[browneyes106]

I wish the finale would have been a bit better.

 

[dahirsh]

Besides Mass Murders are usually loners....that why I was thinkin Jimmy!

who said Jimmy was a loner? He was close to Shane and seemed close to others of the locals.