We stayed at BC for 4 nights last fall with our 4 mo old DD. It was nice, but I don't think worth the price for our priorities on a Disney vacation.
Pro's:
1. Able to walk to Epcot and the Boardwalk areas. For me, this would be the reason I would return to BC. I loved to be able to just run over to Epcot on a whim rather than have to take a bus. My husband was golfing one afternoon so I just loaded my daughter into her stroller and we just took a walk around the World Showcase and the Boardwalk.
2. I hear that Stormalong Bay is nice, but we never even made it there! When we're at Disney, we spend most of our time at the parks. This will probably change as my DD gets older, but for now, any pool (or even no pool) is sufficient for us.
3. Nice resort experience. I don't remember any noise while we were there. Also, we were in a ground level room by the quiet pool and we had a nice patio.
Con's:
1. Dining choices!!! Like I said above, we spend most of our time in the park and when we get back to the hotel we just want to grab a quick bite. We felt so limited at BC. Beaches & Cream take out was really your only quick option at night (and it was pretty tasty!).
2. The rooms were nice, but I didn't think that they were nice enough to justify the price.
3. Bus transportation was annoying because when we were there it stopped at Swan, Dolphin, YC and BC. The boat ride to MGM was enjoyable, but slow.
Would I stay at BC again? Probably, if I had a good rate and if I thought that we would use the pool more. My biggest gripe was the lack of quick food options, but you also have the option of running over to Epcot or the Boardwalk for more options. It's a very nice hotel, but it just didn't fit our needs.