We've done 2 cruises - the first my DD was 3 1/2 and the second she was 5 1/5. Both times she was addicted to the Club and it was sheer force to get her out of there for pool time and other things. She loved doing meals with the group, the dress-up time, movie time at night, and all of the individual activities. I've only been paged once when she was 3 1/2 and was not wanting to stick with the group. I told her she'd have to come with me, and she promised she'd go along with the flow after that. That was the end of the paging. Next time DD will be in the Lab and DS in the Club - I only hope he enjoys it as much!