Tell me what you think

[pkdof]

Going 3/27-30 with DD16 and DS16, both foodies. We're trying the DxDP. We are definitely doing the following:

California Grill
Cape May breakfast
Crystal Palace breakfast
Dine w/Imagineer at HBD lunch (I know, it's OOP)

We're doing either Via Napoli or Tutto Italia for lunch

And need help deciding the last two dinners, either:

Narcoosee's
Yachtsman
Flying Fish

What are your thoughts?

 

[MPHARJ]

California Grill - On our list this year, haven't been in about 10 years
Cape May breakfast - one of our favorites for breakfast and dinner
Crystal Palace breakfast - another we enjoy for breakfast over the other meals
Dine w/Imagineer at HBD lunch - haven't done this
Via Napoli - trying this year, wasn't open when we were there last year
Narcoosee's -on our list this year too
Flying Fish - love FF and we are going again this year

 

[sammysmom]

We have been to both Narcoosee's and Yachtsman's and they are both really good. We usually go to them every year. Never been to Flying Fish, but have heard wonderful things about the restaurant. Have you ever tried Cape May for dinner? Their seafood buffet is excellent Good luck with your final choices.

 

[Pakey]

Flying Fish is much better than both Narcoosees and Yachtsman. I have dined at all of them many times so this is based on an average rather than a one time instance.

 

[Pakey]

And I liked Via Napoli better than Tutto but I've only been to Via Napoli once. I thought it was closer to true Italian food I was served in Italy. But the place is noisy, Tutto has a better dining environment.

 

[pkdof]

I'm trying to not only eat at great restaurants, but maximize my DxDP value, so we're skipping Cape May dinner this time. Seem's like Narcoosee's and Flying Fish might be the way to go? Leave Yachtsman out?

 

[EvilQueenT]

flying fish is a must do for us. imo flying fish is more consistent in both service and getting a good meal as compared to narcoossee's which for us has been hit or miss over 4 trips.

a lot of people on these boards say yachtmans is at least as good as and many say better than le cellier but i have not eaten there personally. we've been to california grill 3 times (the last time was early dec 2010) and were very disappointed as compared to our trip in 07. the food wasn't prepared well and we had the worst service of our trip. citricos was much better imo.