slo’s THURSDAY 10/9 poll - Fluffernutter Sandwiches 🥪

AppleDumpling · 2025-10-09T10:01:16-0400

They were popular when I was a kid, but I never cared for marshmallow, so always just had plain peanut butter or PB&J sandwiches. Didn’t like Scooter Pies or Mallomars either (maybe also regional). LOL, I actually still remember the jingle posted by @leebee above.

_19disnA · 2025-10-09T10:12:00-0400

Don't like that marshmallow fluff so nothing I would ever eat.

Pea-n-Me · 2025-10-09T10:18:07-0400

I grew up in the area where these originated, too.

I love them, my kids loved them, and we still enjoy them today.

I keep Fluff on hand for those and my hot chocolate! :goodvibes

slo’s THURSDAY 10/9 poll - Fluffernutter Sandwiches 🥪

Fluffernutter Sandwiches - Questions in post below ⬇️

Yes - I eat Fluffernutters

I used to eat Fluffernutters

I love them ❤️

I like them 🙂👍🏻

They are just ok 😐

I do not like them 🙁👎🏻

I’ve never had a Fluffernutter - I’d like to try

I’ve never had a Fluffernutter - I have no desire to try

I can’t eat peanut butter, so no Fluffernutters for me

Other - please post your answer

AppleDumpling

DIS Legend

_19disnA

DIS Veteran

Pea-n-Me

DIS Legend

DIS News & Updates

New Threads

New Posts

New Posts